Cabinetry Options: Understanding the Differences between Pre Fabricated, Semi – Custom and Custom Cabinetry

Cabinets are one of the biggest and most expensive design choices in any space and the type you choose can make all the difference in the style of your space, functionality and quality.

There are different types of cabinetry. Many people are often unaware and surprised when selecting their cabinetry, as not all cabinets are created equal.   This means that cabinets can vary greatly in terms of quality, cost, and durability; they are simply not the same across the board. 

Cabinets can be categorized into three main types: custom , semi-custom , and prefabricated . 

Prefab Cabinets  

Basic prefab cabinetry can be a significant cost-saver.  Prefab cabinets are straightforward; you get exactly what you see. 

Consider the cabinets typically found in local home improvement stores that can be purchased directly off the shelf; these are prime examples of prefab cabinets. While the price tag can be enticing, if this area of your home is something you’ve long dreamed about and saved for, we recommend investing in higher-quality cabinetry. This approach will help you avoid the need to remodel the same space again in just a few years due to poor quality. 

Pros: 

• Cost Efficiency : Prefabricated cabinets are highly affordable.
  • Many suppliers offer samples or entire cabinets to see and touch, making it easier to visualize them in your desired space, while others rely on online visuals that may differ in reality. 

Cons: 

• Limited Options : While these cabinets are cost-effective, the durability often suffers.   The paint used on prefab cabinets isn’t subpar, but it might not hold up as well as a custom cabinet paint job. 
• Customization Restrictions : Rarely can you paint over prefab cabinets, and the limited options available can hinder those with unique space requirements. 

Semi-Custom Cabinetry 

Semi-custom cabinetry, like in this Easton, PA kitchen remodel, strikes a balance between prefabricated and custom options, offering the benefits of both.   You enjoy the affordable quality of prefab cabinets while having limited—but valuable—options for customization.

In our projects, particularly in the kitchen, we only use semi-custom and custom cabinetry. Semi-custom cabinets typically come with a lower price tag than fully custom options. However, they allow for simple design choices, such as integrating custom floating shelves, adding extra trim work to elevate the look and cabinetry around appliances like microwaves, as seen in our Timeless Coastal project.

This semi – custom kitchen leaned more towards custom, as we integrated glass cabinets, open shelving, specialty molding, and custom paneling for the appliances.

With prefab options, such changes aren’t feasible due to their standard cabinetry box sizes.   In contrast, semi-custom cabinets ship quickly, offer a diverse selection, and yield a strong final product. 

Pros: 

• Great Options and Variety of Selections : Semi-custom cabinets provide a wider range of choices in colors, stains, and styles then a pre fab.   Although they are mass-produced, their quality is much better then pre fab and comes close to that of custom cabinets. 
• Adjustable Sizes : You can customize cabinet sizes, alleviating layout headaches in your kitchen.   For example, a bathroom vanity can be tailored to fit snugly into a specific opening, which prefab options cannot accommodate, often resulting in unsightly gaps. 
• Variety of Moldings : They come with a wide array of moldings that can match or coordinate elegantly with your cabinetry. 
• Turnaround Time : The average delivery time for semi-custom cabinets ranges from one week to one month, depending on the supplier. 
• Affordable Mid Range Option: The average cost of semi custom cabinets for a 200-300 square foot kitchen ranges between $20,000 – $35,000.

Cons: 

• Paint Quality : The main drawback of semi-custom cabinets is the quality of the paint.   Repeatedly, we observe a noticeable difference between the paint finishes on custom versus semi-custom cabinets.   While semi-custom isn’t bad, custom lines are significantly superior.   The cost savings from mass production typically lead to a decline in quality. 
• Limited Design : While more options then pre fab, semi custom cabinets do have design limitations in styles, colors and wood species available. 
• Fillers for Measurements : Semi-custom lines often require “fillers” between cabinets to achieve desired measurements.   For example, if you have a wall spanning 75 inches, and two lower cabinets measuring a total of 72 inches, a 3-inch filler is added for a tight fit against each wall.   While a filler can be made to be unnoticeable, it often results in a cleaner and higher-quality finish when fillers aren’t necessary. 

Custom Cabinetry

 What exactly is custom cabinetry?   In essence, it refers to cabinetry that is specifically designed and built for your unique project.   During the design phase, we create a custom cabinetry design tailored to your unique needs and preferences. Once we’ve finalized the design, we hand it over to our skilled cabinet maker, who brings the vision to life.

Custom cabinetry, as seen in this Nazareth, PA kitchen, is essential for achieving a tight, flush fit in designated areas allowing cabinets to fit perfectly from wall to wall and floor to ceiling. 

However, the process of crafting custom cabinetry requires significant time and attention to detail.   Cabinet makers can spend weeks meticulously building your ideal product.   While the wait may be lengthy, the investment is well worthwhile. 

Custom cabinetry remains our favorite choice, largely due to its quality but also because the design options are limitless.    

One notable advantage of custom cabinets is the many different cabinet styles and cabinetry details that can be achieved.

That gorgeous full – height appliance pantry you saw on instagram?  Yes, it can be made with custom cabinets!

The beautiful reeding on that walnut stained island you saw in Home and Gardens?  It can be done with custom.

 The ability to extend to the ceiling, eliminating that bothersome gap above cabinets that collects dust? You bet! 

Now that we understand what custom cabinetry is, let’s explore the reasons why you might consider using it in your home. 

Pros: 

• Top-Notch Product : When comparing prefab cabinets to custom options, custom cabinetry represents the pinnacle of quality.   The craftsmanship is exceptional, and you won’t find anything better. 
• Superior Finish : Custom cabinets are often sprayed in a professional paint shop and properly cured, resulting in minimal cracking, enhanced durability, and a polished finish. 
• Limitless Design Opportunities : A custom cabinet maker can accommodate specific requests, allowing for virtually endless design possibilities.   For instance, if you need a 13.5-inch wide cabinet—an option difficult to locate in prefab lines—a custom maker can create it for you.   You can also choose any paint color, wood species and stains you desire. Pre fab and semi custom are limited in their design options, paint colors available and types of wood.
• High – End Look: Custom cabinetry delivers the highest end look due to the perfect fit, unique styles and quality.

Cons: 

• High Price Point : The exceptional quality and design options of custom cabinetry comes with a higher price tag.   Custom cabinets can range from $35,000 to $55,000 for a standard kitchen ( 200 – 300 square feet), which may deter some clients.  

Ultimately, we work with both semi and custom cabinetry but if budget allows we encourage custom cabinetry.

Why We Believe Custom Cabinetry Matters

Every space is unique, especially when working with existing conditions. We maximize every square inch of cabinetry for storage, eliminating fillers or dead space whenever possible. With custom cabinetry, I can ensure that all your storage needs are met, from spices to oversized platters.

Your Cabinets are an Investment

Think about it: how many times will you remodel your kitchen in your lifetime? Once, maybe twice? A well-made custom cabinet can last up to 50 years, while pre-fabricated ones start to look worn after just 2-3 years. Don’t settle for buyer’s remorse – if you can, invest in custom cabinetry.

Budget-Friendly Alternatives

If you’re doing a larger project, consider doing pre fab for areas like bathroom vanities or stand-alone storage pieces. These are easier on the budget and can still hold up well over time.

For this powder room, we used a high quality, pre fab vanity with quartz countertop.

Customization Beyond the Kitchen

Mudrooms, offices, and drop zones can also benefit from custom cabinetry. These high-use spaces usually require specific storage solutions that pre-fabricated options can’t provide.

We would love to discuss cabinetry options with you for your home.

Fill out our form below to tell us about your upcoming project.